Replica Watch Reviews & Factory Comparisons

Comprehensive analysis of premium replica timepieces across different factories, featuring detailed specifications, movement comparisons, and expert analysis.

NWBIG - Not Worth Buying In Gen

1:1 Quality

Mid Tier

Brand	Model	Reference	Price	Size (mm)	Thickness	Factory	Movement	Pros	Cons
Audemars Piguet	Royal Oak	15400	$50,000	41	9.8	ZF APSF	SA3120 SA3120	Solid build quality, reliable movement Accurate dial pattern, Correct case proportions	Case finishing could be better Less sharp finishing
Audemars Piguet	Royal Oak	15410	$26,000	41	10.4	APSF	SA3120	Solid build quality, reliable movement, good lume	Date wheel alignment, rotor noise
Audemars Piguet	Royal Oak	15450	$26,000	37	9.8	ZF APSF	SA3120 SA3120	Accurate case proportions Thinner case profile, Updated movement design	Slightly thicker case Case finishing not as refined as APSF
Audemars Piguet	Royal Oak	15500	$35,000	41	10.4	ZF APSF	SA4302 SA4302	V3 improvements, stable movement Best dial accuracy, perfect case finishing	Less sharp case edges Minor detail imperfections
Audemars Piguet	Royal Oak	15510	$30,000	41	10.4	ZF APSF	SA4302 SA4302	Superior case and bracelet finish. Features a true clone movement.	Noticeably noisy winding rotor. Slightly thicker case profile.
Audemars Piguet	Royal Oak	15550	$26,000	41	10.4	IPF TWF	MY9015 MY9015	Superior case and bracelet finishing, highly accurate dial replication. More affordable price point, Offers many dial color options.	No good clone movements yet, basic finishing Dial tapisserie is less sharp, Case finishing is less refined.
Audemars Piguet	Royal Oak	16202	$45,000	39	8.1	ZF	A7121	Extremely thin case profile.	Incorrect balance wheel position.
Audemars Piguet	Royal Oak	15202	$145,000	39	8.1	ZF XF BF	A2121 A2121 A2121	Best case finishing, accurate thickness, superior bracelet Good value, solid build quality Budget friendly, decent appearance	Higher price, limited availability Discontinued, thicker case Lower quality finishing, incorrect thickness
Audemars Piguet	Royal Oak	26240	$60,000	41	12.4	APSF DDF	SH4401 DD4401	Excellent case work, reliable chronograph function Superior dial quality, accurate subdial spacing	Higher price point, limited availability Newer factory, less proven track record
Breitling	Avenger	44mm	$3,450	43	12.2	BLSF TF	A2824 A2824	Robust build quality, accurate case dimensions Superior dial printing, solid bracelet construction	Movement decoration could be better Crown guards slightly thick
Breitling	Avenger	B01 Chrono 45mm	$5,500	45	16.5	BLSF	B01 Clone	Premium chronograph movement, excellent case finishing	Large case size, high price point
Breitling	Navitimer	41mm	$4,700	41	10	V7F TF BLSF	A2824 A2824 A2824	Superior dial and crystal AR. More accessible, lower price. Good value for the money	decorated movement. Noticeably sunken date wheel. Slide rule can be stiff initially
Breitling	Navitimer	41mm Chrono	$4,700	41	10	BLSF	Asian B01	Chrono function, comprehensive features	Some dials may vary in color.
Breitling	SuperOcean	Heritage	$3,850	42	14.35	BLSF	A2824	Excellent water resistance, vintage-inspired design	some in big noise, bezel action could be improved
Cartier	Tank	Must	$3,500	25.5*31	6.6	AF F1 K11F	Quartz Quartz Quartz	Superior curved dome crystal. Excellent overall value proposition. Solid build quality	Stock leather strap is subpar. Case edges can feel sharp. Crystal has a flat profile, crown cabochon is too pointy.
Cartier	Tank	Louis	$12,000	22/25.5	6.6	DRF K11F AF	Ronda 1042 Ronda 1042 Ronda 1042	Excellent case finishing, accurate proportions Accurate grained dial texture. Excellent curved dome crystal.	Printing slightly less crisp. Crystal has a flat profile. Inconsistent crown cabochon color.
Cartier	Tank	Francaise	$4,000	22/27	7	8848F BVF	Ronda 763 Ronda 763	Good overall value proposition. Excellent bracelet articulation, finish.	Dial printing not as sharp. Crown cabochon can be dark.
Cartier	Dumont	WSSA002X	$4,350	27.5/31.4	7.3	F1F AF	Swiss Ronda Swiss Ronda	Excellent case finishing, accurate proportions Superior dial quality, reliable movement	Subpar stock leather strap. Dial printing is slightly softer.
Cartier	Santos	WSSA00XX W2SA00XX WGSA00XX	$6,850	35/40	8.83	V6F BVF AF GF	MY9015 MY9015 MY9015 Miyota 9015	Excellent case finishing Corrected Cartier 'R' printing. Generally a more affordable option. Superb SmartLink bracelet system.	Limited availability Noisy automatic movement rotor. Dial printing lacks sharpness. Common floating 'R' dial flaw.
IWC	Big Pilot	Big Pilot (SS)	$10,000	46	15.5	ZF	A52850	Excellent case finishing, accurate proportions	Movement rotor can be noisy, Indicator isn't true 7-day reserve.
IWC	Big Pilot	Big Pilot Annual Calendar	-	46.2	15.5	AZF	A52850	Complex calendar functions, premium finishing	Thick, calendar setup complexity
IWC	Big Pilot	Big Pilot Miramar	$10,500	46	15	ZF	A51111	Accurate matte ceramic case finish.	Rotor can be quite noisy.
IWC	Big Pilot	Mark XVIII and XX (Ceramic)	$14,500	40	11	M+F	MY9015	Premium ceramic case, scratch resistant, Functional EasX-CHANGE bracelet system.	Date window placement slightly off.
IWC	Pilot	Mark XVIII and XX	$5,000	40	10.8	V7F M+F ZF	A2892 MY9015 A32111	Good value, reliable movement Excellent matte dial texture. Exceptional AR coated crystal.	Date font slightly too bold. Uses a generic clone movement Higher price
IWC	Pilot	Pilot Chrono 3777	$5,300	43	15	ZF	A7750	Functional chronograph, classic design	Thick case, chronograph reliability
IWC	Portugieser	IW5007 / IW5001	$8,300	41	11	ZF APSF	A52010 A52010	Superior clone movement decoration, quieter automatic rotor winding. Razor-sharp dial numeral printing, exceptional case polishing and finish.	Dial printing can be softer. Movement has a decorated plate, some can be noisy.
IWC	Portugieser	IW3716	$8,300	41	11	ZF	A69355	Chronograph complication, refined case	Complex movement servicing
IWC	Portofino	IW3565XX	$5,000	40/41	-	ZF MKSF	A9019 A35800	Superior decorated movement appearance. Excellent overall value proposition.	Date window alignment sometimes off. Date font not always perfect.
IWC	Ingenieur	3236xx	$12,300	40	11	V7F	A2892	Anti-magnetic properties, robust construction	High price point, limited availability
JLC	Master Ultra Thin	1368470	$8,950	39	9.9	ZF APSF IMF	A896/1 A896/1 Miyota 9015	Superior case polishing and feel. Thinner and more accurate case., 3D Moon Phase Display Good value option	Inaccurate moonphase disc color/texture. Case finishing not at ZF-level. Basic movement decoration
JLC	Master Ultra Thin	Q1302520	$18,500	39	12	VRF	A868	Multi-functional	Decorated movement
JLC	Master Ultra Thin	Q1212510	$8,000	38.5	9	APSF	A896	Fully functional perpetual calendar.	Calendar setting 'danger zone' risk
JLC	Reverso	Q38585XX	$12,500	40	11.8	MGF	A854A	Unique flip case mechanism Accurate case proportions Good dial execution	Complex mechanism reliability Thick case profile Uses painted, not blued, hands.
Omega	Seamaster 300	All models	$12,000	41	13.5	VSF	DD8800	Excellent case finishing Accurate dial details Strong lume application	Movement decoration lacks depth Bracelet clasp feel Logo alignment
Omega	Seamaster	Aqua Terra 150m	$4,500	41	13.2	VSF	A8900	Teak dial pattern accuracy Solid bracelet construction	Date wheel alignment Crown operation smoothness
Omega	Seamaster	WorldTimer	$12,000	43	14	VSF	A8938	Complex GMT function works World cities printing quality Titanium case execution	Thick case profile Complex servicing requirements Premium pricing tier
Omega	Seamaster	No Time to Die	$10,500	42	13.15	VSF	A8806	Mesh bracelet quality Light same material as gen Titanium case and band	Expensive Mesh bracelet comfort
Omega	Seamaster	Ultra Deep 6000M	-	45.5	18	VSF	A8912	Extreme depth rating Titanium construction Unique case design	Massive case dimensions Limited wrist compatibility Niche market appeal
Patek Philippe	Calatrava	5227	$39,000	39	8.3	3KF ZF	A324 SC A324 SC	Superb case finishing Accurate dial proportions	Clone movement reliability is questionable. Incorrect officer's caseback hinge mechanism.
Patek Philippe	Nautilus	5711	$100,000	40	8.3	DDF 3KF	DD330 324 SC Clone	Perfect bracelet integration Excellent dial texture	High price Movement isnt 1:1
Patek Philippe	Nautilus	5711 DiW Variants	$192,000	40	8.3	DiWF	Cal.324 SC Clone	Unique carbon fiber finish	Extremely expensive
Patek Philippe	Nautilus	5711 Iced Out	$150,000	40	8.3	R8F	Cal.324 SC Clone	Full diamond setting	Very high price point
Patek Philippe	Nautilus	5712 Moonphase	$85,000	40	8.52	OME PPF	A240 A240	Functional power reserve indicator Most accurate dial color/texture	Incorrectly saturated (too blue) dial. Case profile is too thick
Patek Philippe	Nautilus	5726 Annual Calendar	$52000	40.5	11.3	DDF 3KF	DD330 A324	Best movement, thin Excellent dial texture	High price Moderated movement, thick
Patek Philippe	Nautilus	5811 Blue	$190,000	41	8.2	3KF DDF	330SC DD330	Beautiful blue dial Best movement	Not 1:1 movement Limited production high price
Patek Philippe	Nautilus	5980 Chrono	$95,000	40.5	12.2	PPF TWF	A25-520 A7750	Working chronograph Cheap	Thick case profile Complex movement
Patek Philippe	Nautilus	7118 Ladies 35mm	$68,000	35	8.6	3KF PPF	A324 A324	Ideal ladies size,better movement Quality bracelet	Higher price point Moderated movement
Patek Philippe	Aquanaut	5167A	$54,300	40	6.63	3KF DDF	A324 SC DD324	Perfect rubber strap, fast Excellent case shape, best movement	Date font is slightly bold. High price, slow
Rolex	Datejust	41mm/36mm	$12,000	41	12	EWF GMF ARF Clean VSF	A3235 A3235 SH3235 SH3235 VS3235	Good movement quality Multiple dial colors available Weighted rotor, premium feel Best case shape and details Best movement and crystal	Limited dial options Basic movement 0.5mm thicker than gen Higher price point Premium pricing
Rolex	Day-Date	40mm	$40,000	40	13.1	GMF BPF QF THB	VR3255 A2836 VR3255 VR3255	Good movement, multiple dial options Budget option available Weighted rotor, premium feel Best overall quality, weighted	Standard finishing quality, slow Basic movement, lower quality Higher price point Slow
Rolex	Daytona	11xxxxx	$36,995	40	12.5	VSF BTF CLEAN	DD4130 SA4130 DD4130	Best movement Refined, thinner chronograph hands Best overall quality and finishing	Slow Dial printing slightly less sharp Bracelet SEL fit can vary
Rolex	Daytona	126500LN	$36,450	40	12.5	CLEAN QF VSF	VS4131 SH4131 VS4131	Excellent case finishing, accurate dial details Competitive price point alternative, tungsten materials,weighted Best movement decoration, top-tier build	Initial crystal can have flaws ezel proportions are less accurate. Long wait times
Rolex	Air-King	116900	$10,500	40	13	GMF	A2824	Solid build quality, reliable movement, good value	Limited availability, basic finishing
Rolex	Air-King	126900	$11,000	40	13	CLEAN VSF JVSF	VR3230 VS3230 VR3230	Best dial accuracy, excellent crown guards Best movement, reliable workhorse Exceptional value for the money.	Crystal can have milky gasket., closed Details can be removed Bracelet quality below top tier
Rolex	Cellini	Generic	$28,000	39	12	GMF	A3132	Elegant dress watch design, quality leather strap	Limited factory options, niche market appeal
Rolex	Explorer I	124270	$11,000	36	11.5	VSF CLEAN	VS3230 VR3230	Superior movement finishing, accurate proportions Excellent dial printing, solid bracelet	Higher cost, occasional QC issues Longer delivery times
Rolex	Explorer I	214270	$8,950	39	13	CLEAN	VR3132	Great work, reliable movement	Closed
Rolex	Explorer I	224270	$10,500	40	11.5	VSF CLEAN	VS3230 VR3230	Premium movement quality, no ghost date gear Consistent quality, good availability	Premium pricing tier Standard movement decoration
Rolex	GMT Master II	116710LN	$14,500	40	12	CLEAN C+F ARF	VR3186 VR3285 A3186	Best GMT function, excellent bezel quality Competitive pricing, decent quality Superior bracelet quality, good finishing	Premium pricing, limited availability Basic movement, inconsistent QC Outdated movement
Rolex	GMT Master II	Pepsi Batman Sprite Bruce wayne	$18,995	40	12	VSF CLEAN ARF	VS3285 VS3285 SH3285	Best-in-class movement, perfect bezel colors Best-in-class ceramic bezel insert. Excellent case finishing, accurate proportions	Highest price point, long wait times Crystal gasket is too visible. Bezel insert colors are inferior, crown guards slightly thick
Rolex	GMT Master II	126711CHNR (Rootbeer)	$21,000	40	12	CLEAN ARF	DD3285 SH3285	Excellent rose gold plating, functional GMT Good bracelet weight, solid construction	Very expensive, closed Bezel insert colors are inferior, crown guards slightly thick
Rolex	Milgauss	116400	$9,500	40	13	VSF GSF	VS3131 SH3131	Unique orange lightning hand, quality crystal Highly accurate Z-Blue dial, superior green sapphire crystal	Limited availability, niche appeal Bracelet finish slightly less refined.
Rolex	Oyster Perpetual	36mm	$7,000	36/41	11.8	CLEAN VSF EWEF	VR3230 VS3230 A3230	Most accurate dial color replication Superior movement quality Budget-friendly, multiple color options	Movement considered second to VSF Higher pricing, slow Uses a cheaper decorated movement
Rolex	Sky-Dweller	All Models	$20,000	42	14	ZF NOOB	A2824 A23J	Functional "Ring Command" rotating bezel More color options	Bezel rotation can feel rough Inconsistent quality, reliability issues
Rolex	Submariner	114060	$12,500	40	12.5	CLEAN VSF	VS3130 VS3130	Excellent no-date simplicity, perfect proportions Superior movement decoration, best bezel action	Premium pricing, limited availability Long wait times
Rolex	Submariner	116610LN/LV	$13,500	40	12.5	VSF CLEAN	VS3135 VS3135	Best-in-class overall quality, perfect date wheel Excellent value, reliable performance	Premium tier pricing Longer delivery times
Rolex	Submariner	124060	$12,500	41	12.5	VSF CLEAN	VS3230 VR3230	Latest generation case, superior movement, no ghost date Good alternative, best movement	Premium pricing, limited stock Longer lead times
Rolex	Submariner	126610LN/LV	$14,500	41	12.5	VSF CLEAN	VS3235 VR3235	Latest generation excellence, perfect proportions Solid build quality, good availability	Highest pricing tier, exclusive availability Premium cost structure
Rolex	Yacht-Master	1266XX	$14,500	40	-	VSF CLEAN	VS3235 VR3235	Exceptional crystal and cyclops, Tungsteel Most accurate dial and sunburst.	Dial sunburst effect weakerdiv> Movement second best to VSF
Rolex	Yacht-Master	226627 Titanium	$39,950	42	12	CLEAN QF TW	VR3235 AH3235 A2824	Titanium case construction, lightweight feel Competitive pricing, decent quality Budget option, basic reliability	Extremely expensive, limited availability Quality inconsistencies Basic movement, limited finishing
Tudor	Black Bay	BB58	$3,500	39	12	ZF	A2824	Excellent case finishing, authentic slim case profile.	Crown tube slightly thick, uses a decorated A2824 movement
Tudor	Black Bay	Heritage 36	$2,850	36	11.9	KRF	A2824	Perfect vintage proportions, good lume, SW200 available	Limited availability, dial color slightly off in certain lighting
Tudor	Black Bay	Heritage Chronograph	$5,000	42	14.9	TWF	A7750	Functional chronograph	Complex movement maintenance, Dysfunction, thick case
Tudor	Black Bay	Chrono	$4,150	39	11.9	ZF	DD7750	Perfect vintage sizing, excellent gilt details, premium feel	Limited production runs, waiting times, premium pricing
Tudor	Black Bay	GMT	$4,300	41	14.6	ZF	A2836	Functional GMT, accurate bezel, solid bracelet construction	Noticeably long crown tube
Tudor	Pelagos	FXD Red Bull Chrono	$4675	42	14.5	M+F	8N24	Unique Red Bull branding, Well-machined titanium bezel	Case is noticeably thicker
Tudor	Pelagos	FXD Time Only	$4,500	42	12.7	M+F	8N24	Accurate case and lugs	Bezel action lacks refinement
Tudor	Pelagos	FXD Titanium GMT	$5,475	42	14.5	M+F	A2824	Accurate titanium case finishing.	Weak and soft bezel action
Tudor	Pelagos	Left Hand Diver (LHD)	$4,700	42	14.3	XF	A2824	Left-handed crown design, titanium construction, unique appeal	Limited market appeal, crown position takes adjustment, slow
Tudor	Pelagos	Titanium	$5600	42	14.3	ZF XF	A2824 A2824	Lightweight titanium, excellent lume, best replicated clasp mechanism Superior case finishing, accurate helium valve	Bracelet micro-adjustment issues,potential crown threading issues. Bezel pip often misaligned
Vacheron Constantin	Overseas	2000V	$19,950	41	11	XF	MY9015	Excellent case finishing, accurate dial details	Movement decoration visible through caseback
Vacheron Constantin	Overseas	4500V	$32,000	41	11	ZF MKS	A5100 A5100	Best overall quality and finishing Budget friendly option	Movement with decorated plate Less dynamic dial sunburst, poor date wheel alignment
Vacheron Constantin	Overseas	47040	$17,950	42	9.7	PPF MKS	A1226 MY9019	Stunning and accurate dial Good value proposition	Movement decoration is inaccurate Noticeably thicker than genuine.